Tech News

Schools Weigh Ditching Google Search: Questions Parents Should Ask

Back to Blog & News
Students using laptops in a classroom, illustrating school districts seeking Google Search alternatives over AI features

New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago public schools are weighing alternatives to Google Search, according to reporting from The Verge and Digital Trends, both citing The New York Times. The sticking point is that Google says it can’t give student accounts a version of Search without its AI features.

The short version

  • Google said in a blog post that in early 2027, Search, Gemini, Gemini Notebook and Gemini in Classroom will be off by default for K-12 student accounts until administrators turn them on, per Digital Trends.
  • Schools can reportedly enable Search without the stand-alone Gemini tools, but not without AI Overviews or AI Mode. Google has said those features are “deeply integrated.”
  • NYC Schools Chancellor Kamar H. Samuels said: “If Google doesn’t reconsider their position, we will explore other search options,” according to The Verge.
  • Chicago Public Schools has reportedly told Google it will “look to other search solutions” if it can’t get Search without AI.
  • Los Angeles Unified has turned off AI Overviews for students and is weighing whether Search belongs in classrooms at all, a spokesperson told NBC LA, per Digital Trends.
  • The reports describe districts considering a switch. None says one has been completed.

Where Google and the districts disagree

Chris Phillips, Google’s vice president of education, told the Times that “Search and AI are deeply integrated,” and that schools turning off AI features “will not have access to Search,” The Verge reports. Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Sen. Bernie Sanders called that approach “extortion,” according to The Verge.

Google frames it differently. Spokesperson Laura Breen told The Verge the company is piloting Guided Learning in Search this month, which walks students through problems step by step instead of giving quick answers. She also said Search and the Gemini tools will be off by default until schools choose to enable them. NYC has declined the Guided Learning pilot, Digital Trends reports.

The two accounts aren’t necessarily in conflict. Off by default is not the same as removable. Schools can reportedly keep Search off, but turning it on brings AI Overviews and AI Mode with it.

What it means for students and parents

If no chatbot-free Search emerges, students in these districts could lose Search on their Chromebooks or keep getting AI answers, Digital Trends says. Switching isn’t trivial. The Verge notes Google is deeply embedded in US classrooms through Google Classroom and Chromebooks.

Teachers worry students will use the chatbots to cheat or read AI summaries instead of original sources, per Digital Trends. The Verge adds that some studies have shown students who use AI generally perform worse on tests. Some NYC parents have reported that their children can still reach AI Mode at home on school accounts. That’s a parent report, not something either outlet verified.

DuckDuckGo and Bing, the two alternatives named, already let schools turn off AI-generated answers, Digital Trends reports.

Questions to ask your child’s school

Our take: the reports don’t cover student data, so these are suggested questions, not findings.

  1. Which search engine do student accounts use, and are AI Overviews or AI Mode on?
  2. Can students reach AI features at home on school accounts, and who decided that?
  3. If the district switches search engines, what student data does the new provider collect, and under what contract terms?
  4. What is the school’s policy on AI use for assignments, and how is it enforced?
  5. Who can parents contact to change these settings?

What happens next

Analysis, based only on the reporting above. The clock is early 2027, when Google’s new defaults are due. Los Angeles Unified’s CIO, Jack Kelanic, said the district could change its default search engine “literally overnight,” per Digital Trends. So a switch could come fast if Google holds its position. Watch for a Google concession, or a district announcement.

Image: StockSnap / Pixabay

Sources

This article was researched and drafted with AI assistance and reviewed against the linked sources by the Nexonic editorial team.

← More Tech News

Join the conversation

Ready to grow with a digital partner?

Tell us about your business. We will reply with honest advice and a clear plan.